{ "schema": "atlas/v9-arms/2", "kind": "mutation-arms", "measures": "047952b2d82a73a52399f061702a3dc6015cfcb692a126c08d31c90d8e39bc0fi0", "registry": "fac64d8fd1c8436b374d2ce5e73eb432a3ed0de4596e1dc41a7c5abcb6d6a4e8i0", "errata": "34e6965073dc8a499d27af5d2e4d9a2ac447a1ae1d933838dde2d02a5e931dabi0", "sealedSource": { "bytes": 31084, "bytesLF": 30802, "sha256": "26a045570a551abe078e0847c2a04a882bc61d1febb13509c182e90ecf52316b", "lineEndings": "CRLF" }, "check": "apply the edit to a byte-exact copy of the sealed source, then require the registry check to return the declared verdict AND exit code, AND to name the declared rule id among its missing ids", "guards": [ "occurrence: target must occur exactly expectOccurrences times, else NO_BITE", "no-op: mutated body sha256 must differ from source, else NO_CHANGE", "attribution: for an arm with a rule id, that id must be among the missing ids, else MISATTRIBUTED", "disagreement: two independent implementations of the check must agree, else DISAGREE" ], "controlNote": "C1 must stay SUPERSET. It deletes prose that was never registered - the section 0.3 blind spot. Without a green control, 'everything rejects' would look like a passing instrument.", "lastRun": { "at": "2026-11-18T22:01:52-07:00", "arms": 7, "passed": 7, "results": [ { "id": "M1-delete-registered-heading", "observed": "REJECT", "exit": 1, "keptSha256": "972993254b4645e657d1af71da9da469e184e577116b57b3053fffac675a7879", "missing": [ "S-12" ] }, { "id": "M2-rewrite-registered-sentence", "observed": "REJECT", "exit": 1, "keptSha256": "2026e5696e9bb09b1bb0fd77c2f219f63f0d69070a4c72a07101cfed77b53c86", "missing": [ "S-07" ] }, { "id": "M3-rename-registered-rule", "observed": "REJECT", "exit": 1, "keptSha256": "05d11315b88d008ba3d324bc7cb72b5dd41921d7a4e6bf2d0ddb2e0bcde2cd5c", "missing": [ "S-18" ] }, { "id": "M4-negate-registered-conclusion", "observed": "REJECT", "exit": 1, "keptSha256": "91cd110c8a8ff4a170425c307b88b24126ca45b5ab528147a305a70b49928b4e", "missing": [ "S-33" ] }, { "id": "M5-open-closed-enum", "observed": "REJECT", "exit": 1, "keptSha256": "8cab2dabdca5b323b55cb6e7e71c6c70938c506431cc9ec5ff1ddbf25dcd2e0c", "missing": [ "S-35" ] }, { "id": "M6-flip-unaddressable", "observed": "REJECT", "exit": 1, "keptSha256": "074207f1684fdb584783512d325ed5a74abb71e05d94f995f7895402ab344a1e", "missing": [ "S-36" ] }, { "id": "C1-delete-unregistered-prose", "observed": "SUPERSET", "exit": 0, "keptSha256": "a07cc1bf0588d62af0b756215425f3051d4fa899e0829f12316de9362cb75fd4", "missing": [] } ] }, "arms": [ { "id": "M1-delete-registered-heading", "rule": "S-12", "intent": "delete a registered heading", "find": "### Maximality, not recency", "replace": "", "expect": "REJECT", "expectExit": 1, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "remove-anchor", "control": false }, { "id": "M2-rewrite-registered-sentence", "rule": "S-07", "intent": "rewrite a registered sentence", "find": "A default must be visibly defaulted.", "replace": "A default should be visibly defaulted.", "expect": "REJECT", "expectExit": 1, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "alter-anchor-text", "control": false }, { "id": "M3-rename-registered-rule", "rule": "S-18", "intent": "rename a registered rule", "find": "guard_red_arm", "replace": "red_arm", "expect": "REJECT", "expectExit": 1, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "alter-anchor-text", "control": false }, { "id": "M4-negate-registered-conclusion", "rule": "S-33", "intent": "soften a closing consequence to its negation", "find": "A version number alone is not a lineage", "replace": "A version number alone is a lineage", "expect": "REJECT", "expectExit": 1, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "alter-anchor-text", "control": false }, { "id": "M5-open-closed-enum", "rule": "S-35", "intent": "weaken the closed kind list to an open one", "find": "`kind` is a CLOSED enum", "replace": "`kind` is an OPEN enum", "expect": "REJECT", "expectExit": 1, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "alter-anchor-text", "control": false }, { "id": "M6-flip-unaddressable", "rule": "S-36", "intent": "flip \"unaddressable is not the same as lost\" to \"is the same as\"", "find": "Unaddressable is not the same as lost", "replace": "Unaddressable is the same as lost", "expect": "REJECT", "expectExit": 1, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "alter-anchor-text", "control": false }, { "id": "C1-delete-unregistered-prose", "rule": null, "intent": "delete body prose that was never registered", "find": "A green with no red twin is a colour, not information.", "replace": "", "expect": "SUPERSET", "expectExit": 0, "expectOccurrences": 1, "occurrencesInSealed": 1, "mechanicalClass": "unregistered-removal", "control": true } ] }