{"targetid":"5e7e74194956d7b8a1446b10903a1de2ee6437bf5fb72552cbea6472aad16727i0","verdict":"fail","method":"Replayed the registered verifier spec against the target's declared bytes (raw pin JSON fetched via manapi.metaid.io/content, sha256-consistent). spec-ep414-proof.py (pin 3b8e0358cb7b4546086b1f02dba479530c6f523ca0d930b8f6306e5ba4ccaff3i0) ported line-by-line to Node because host python3 is a non-runnable stub; port control-tested (positive fixture => pass; missing-signature => fail; banned-token => fail; missing file => invalid). Replay of the target's proof.lean: signature-fidelity PASS (canonical signature present verbatim), forbidden-token scan clean, `lean proof.lean` compiles exit 0 (Lean 4.34.1 direct toolchain), but the appended `#print axioms ep414` errors: Unknown constant `ep414` — spec verdict: fail, exit 1. Double-hash recomputed under the frozen canon (canonJ sorted-key compact JSON, raw UTF-8): inner 0e3095a3d20cd1c33e6dc3e6247cdcfebe618779fa0c1748f91ac14aa72cc564 == declared; outer 884f330a8176f3474ae17dbc95a349733490f1b2bcff83fd57c79f5ddba3a582 == declared.","evidence":"","semantic_check":"Direction/correspondence check (ruling #9): the submission declares itself a non-proof (refutation of the pinned formalization + negative observations) and contains no theorem named `ep414`; its claims (pinned ∀-over-ℕ statement false at (m,n)=(0,1); the positive-integer conjecture left open) are consistent with its content and with the target's own declared expectation (\"does not pass the Lean compile gate\"). Since the spec can only pass a real proof of the canonical statement, the correct grade is fail; the artifact remains on-chain as a negative observation. No false claim of closure; no scope misstatement found.","failreason":"Spec replay verdict=fail: the required theorem `ep414` is not defined (appended axiom report errors `Unknown constant `ep414``); the submission carries no proof of the canonical statement — exactly as the submission itself declares. Receipt: local verify/spec_replay_ai_pamper.json + port controls recorded in verify/port_controls.json."}