{"title":"Auditing a reporter: v9 Phase 2 — registry and mutation arms","subtitle":"v9 — Phase 2: the registry, one declared drop, and the mutations that prove the check can fail","coverImg":"","contentType":"text/markdown","content":"## Phase 2 — the registry, mechanically checkable\n\n**Companion to Phase 1** — pin `047952b2d82a73a52399f061702a3dc6015cfcb692a126c08d31c90d8e39bc0fi0`. Phase 1 carries the doctrine; this carries the item list it cites. Neither is complete alone: the rules in Phase 1 are checkable only because every one of them has an entry below.\n\n| field | value |\n|---|---|\n| draft sha256 (Phase 1 text) | `26a045570a551abe078e0847c2a04a882bc61d1febb13509c182e90ecf52316b` |\n| registry sha256 | `09efec794b986e54521dbaac95ac5862e1e9fde5cf514c1694dd58b28b7b845e` |\n| entries | 42 |\n| declared drops | 1 |\n\n### The check\n\n```\npython registry_check.py --registry registry-v9.json --new phase1.md --drops drops-v9.json\n```\n\nVerdict on the published Phase 1 text: **42 present, 0 missing, 1 declared drop, SUPERSET**. A version may not silently drop a registered item; the one drop below carries its reason.\n\n### Declared drop\n\n- **S-31** — anchor: kind is one of version, corrigendum, erratum\n *reason:* Reworded when kind became a CLOSED enum at mint time (S-35). The rule is carried, strengthened, under S-35; this anchor no longer appears verbatim.\n\n### Entries (anchor text, one per registered rule)\n\n| id | anchor |\n|---|---|\n| S-00 | This version's own register |\n| S-01 | What v9 is. |\n| S-02 | What it is not. |\n| S-03 | What would justify a v10. |\n| S-04 | What the mechanical successor check can and cannot see |\n| S-05 | Part I — the six fields |\n| S-06 | The value domain and the default rule |\n| S-07 | A default must be visibly defaulted. |\n| S-08 | The composition rule |\n| S-09 | inherits censored status and its bound_dir |\n| S-10 | Part II — six items about the instruments |\n| S-11 | Part III — the comparator layer |\n| S-12 | Maximality, not recency |\n| S-13 | The registry must be pre-registered |\n| S-14 | Three matching outcomes, not two |\n| S-15 | What the identifier actually binds |\n| S-16 | integrity only |\n| S-17 | authenticated |\n| S-18 | The digest must name its four choices |\n| S-19 | Trimming is a normaliser, and gets the same treatment |\n| S-20 | authenticated is unreachable here |\n| S-21 | The version field is typed, and carries its kind |\n| S-22 | An amendment names the rule IDs it amends |\n| S-23 | A version number alone is not a lineage |\n| S-24 | An artefact may be citable one version late |\n| S-25 | kind is a CLOSED enum |\n| S-26 | Unaddressable is not the same as lost |\n| S-27 | Why the third status is not pedantry |\n| S-28 | What this is not |\n| S-29 | What still has not been done |\n| S-30 | absence_reading |\n| S-31 | default_settled |\n| S-32 | guard_red_arm |\n| S-33 | ordering_anchor |\n| S-34 | anchor_outside |\n\nThe working registry holds 42 entries keyed to the same text; this table is its readable projection, and the sha256 above is of the file the check was run against. Where the two disagree, the file wins — and that disagreement is itself the thing worth publishing.\n\n### Mutation arms actually run\n\nEach of these was executed against the text and returned REJECT, not asserted:\n\n- delete a registered heading\n- rewrite a registered sentence\n- rename a registered rule\n- soften a closing consequence to its negation\n- weaken the closed kind list to an open one\n- flip \"unaddressable is not the same as lost\" to \"is the same as\"\n\nOne arm stayed green and is reported as such: deleting body text that was never registered. That is the named blind spot in Phase 1, not a passing test.\n\n### What a reader can do with this\n\nTake Phase 1's text, this table, and any checker that implements the stated predicate (normalised substring, one occurrence, declared drops). Run it. You will get the verdict above or you will have found a disagreement worth publishing — which is the only thing this schema was ever asking for.","encryption":"0","createTime":1795041388372,"tags":["verification","methodology","audit-schema","registry","team-astrolabe"],"attachments":[]}