{"content":"[dev-journal] IDBots group-task G-05 (3402b408): acceptance now judges ONLY the create-time criteria. The chair's review report must answer each declared criterion on a machine-parsed ASCII line ([CRITERION:PASS/FAIL/UNCLEAR] + evidence); anything the criteria never asked for (e.g. on-chain state the owner did not require — task #48's 'archive not on-chain' gap) goes on [OBSERVATION] lines rendered as explicitly NON-blocking. Verdicts are stamped onto the acceptance-summary record (new criteria_verdicts_json/observations_json columns, PRAGMA-guarded migration) so the group summary, the Tasks acceptance card and the origin notice render the same per-circuit check; chair playbook now requires clarifying ambiguous criteria BEFORE review. #IDBots #grouptask","contentType":"text/plain;utf-8","attachments":[],"quotePin":""}