{"taskid":"6c1f9106465fbc29f72b58e082470d816c1bbbda9a04d2877e5455a19ba238dei0","node":"spec","result":{"node":"spec","payload_version":"1.0","statement_reference":{"source":"JSP-001024, TheJustinSunPrize/awards, problems/catalog-1001-1022.md (main branch)","url":"https://github.com/TheJustinSunPrize/awards/blob/main/problems/catalog-1001-1022.md#JSP-001024","retrieved":"2026-11-16","verbatim":"For every polarized maximal degeneration of Calabi-Yau n-folds, n>=2, and every epsilon>0, prove that all sufficiently small nonzero fibres have an open subset of at least (1-epsilon) of the Ricci-flat volume admitting a smooth fibration by special Lagrangian n-tori of a common phase. This selects the metric SYZ statement; stronger collapsing and global-duality statements are not required by this entry."},"versions":[{"label":"V1-metric-syz-catalog-literal","slots":{"degeneration":"Polarized maximal degeneration of Calabi-Yau n-folds over a punctured disc (large complex structure limit): a proper flat family X -> Delta with X_t smooth Calabi-Yau for t != 0, X_0 a maximally degenerate fibre, and a fixed polarization (the Kahler class on X_t is the polarization, not an arbitrary class). Maximality is part of the hypothesis; non-maximal degenerations are not covered.","dimension":"n >= 2, exactly as the JSP-001024 entry states. n = 1 is excluded by the entry even though it is classically provable, so no downstream node may use the n = 1 case as evidence for the n >= 2 statement.","epsilon":"Universal quantifier on epsilon placed before the choice of t: for every epsilon > 0 there exists t_0 = t_0(epsilon) > 0 such that for every t with 0 < |t| < t_0 there exists an open subset U_t contained in X_t with Vol_gRF(U_t) >= (1 - epsilon) * Vol_gRF(X_t), volumes taken with respect to the Ricci-flat metric. U_t may depend on both t and epsilon; epsilon is not allowed to shrink with t.","fiber_smoothness":"On U_t the fibration f_t: U_t -> B_t is a smooth (C-infinity) proper surjective submersion whose fibres are compact special Lagrangian n-tori. Smoothness is asserted on U_t only: the complement X_t minus U_t carries the remaining epsilon of volume and no regularity claim is made there, so no statement about the discriminant locus is imported.","phase":"Common phase: a single theta in S^1 (possibly depending on t, never on the fibre) exists such that for every fibre L = f_t^{-1}(b) one has omega restricted to L = 0 and Im(e^{-i theta} Omega) restricted to L = 0, where Omega is the holomorphic n-form of X_t. Fibres of differing phase are not permitted inside one U_t."},"mark":"adopted","reason":"This is the governing text of JSP-001024 read literally, and it is the only reading that cannot be ruled too strong by the entry itself. It is adopted as the frozen interface for lang / pde / hunt / lean. Adopted does NOT assert the conjecture is true: it fixes what would count as a proof of the entry.","sources":["S1","S2","S3"]},{"label":"V2-metric-syz-normalized-phase","slots":{"degeneration":"Identical to V1: polarized maximal degeneration of Calabi-Yau n-folds, polarization fixed, maximality as hypothesis.","dimension":"Identical to V1: n >= 2.","epsilon":"Identical to V1: for every epsilon > 0 there is t_0(epsilon) such that for all 0 < |t| < t_0 an open U_t in X_t satisfies Vol_gRF(U_t) >= (1 - epsilon) * Vol_gRF(X_t).","fiber_smoothness":"Identical to V1: smooth proper submersion on U_t with compact special Lagrangian n-torus fibres; no regularity asserted off U_t.","phase":"Phase normalized to theta = 0 by replacing Omega with e^{i theta} Omega before stating the condition: fibres satisfy omega restricted to L = 0 and Im(Omega) restricted to L = 0 with the rotated form. The rotation is a bijection of S^1 and preserves both the Calabi-Yau structure and the special Lagrangian condition, so no phase is lost."},"mark":"adopted","reason":"Provably equivalent restatement of V1 (Omega -> e^{i theta} Omega is a bijection on the phase circle and leaves omega and the Ricci-flat metric untouched), adopted as the canonical normalization that downstream formalization should use. It exports no obligation beyond V1, so adopting it cannot strengthen the entry; it exists to remove a free parameter from the Lean statement.","sources":["S1","S2"],"equivalence_claim":"V2 <-> V1 by the U(1) rotation of Omega; equivalence is immediate and machine-checkable at the level of definitions, not a mathematical conjecture."},{"label":"V3-metric-syz-gh-semi-flat-strengthened","slots":{"degeneration":"Polarized maximal degeneration as in V1, plus a diameter normalization of the Ricci-flat metrics g_t.","dimension":"n >= 2 as in V1.","epsilon":"for every epsilon > 0, for all sufficiently small t, the complement of U_t has volume at most epsilon, as in V1.","fiber_smoothness":"smooth special Lagrangian n-torus fibration on U_t, plus a metric comparison: g_t restricted to U_t is close in Gromov-Hausdorff (equivalently, in a suitable C^0 sense after normalization) to the semi-flat metric built from the affine structure on the base B_t.","phase":"all fibres of common phase theta, normalize theta = 0."},"mark":"rejected","reason":"Strictly stronger than the JSP-001024 text: the entry asks only for the existence of the smooth special Lagrangian torus fibration on a set of at least (1-epsilon) of the Ricci-flat volume and says stronger statements are not required. Appending Gromov-Hausdorff / semi-flat metric convergence raises the proving obligation and, per the repo mapping note, acceptance does not transfer between problems, so a downstream node proving V3 must not be scored as having proved JSP-001024 without a separate reduction step.","sources":["S1","S3"],"downgrade_path":"Keep as OPTIONAL stronger target for the pde node only, clearly labelled stronger; a V3 result plus an implication V3 => V1 would be legitimate evidence, the V3 result alone is not."},{"label":"V4-original-syz-collapsing-global-duality","slots":{"degeneration":"Any sufficiently large complex structure limit of a mirror pair (X, Y), no polarization fixed and no maximality hypothesis.","dimension":"n = 3 in the original physics setting, with the mirror-pair statement intended for all n.","epsilon":"no epsilon and no volume fraction: the fibration is asserted globally on X, with the singular locus a priori uncontrolled.","fiber_smoothness":"global special Lagrangian T^n fibration on all of X, singular fibres allowed on a discriminant locus whose structure is not bounded, plus the collapsing statement that the Ricci-flat metrics converge to a metric on the base.","phase":"special Lagrangian with respect to a fixed holomorphic volume form, phase allowed to vary over the base in the strong global-duality form."},"mark":"rejected","reason":"This is the 1996 strong form (global torus fibration plus mirror = dual fibration). The JSP-001024 entry explicitly excludes it: stronger collapsing and global-duality statements are not required by this entry, and the 2026-10-20 scope split moved the Hodge-theoretic / KKP and homological-category formulations to separate problems, so this content belongs to other problem ids and must not be imported into this node.","sources":["S1","S2","S4"]}],"excluded_stronger_statements":["Collapsing / Gromov-Hausdorff convergence of the Ricci-flat metrics to the base with codimension-2 discriminant: excluded by the entry text; retained only as a labelled optional target (V3).","Global duality: identification of the mirror with the dual torus fibration including instanton / disc corrections: excluded by the entry text.","KKP Hodge-theoretic noncommutative mirror symmetry: separate problem (MathDB #408863; catalog now cites JSP-001072, the 2026-10-20 PR announced JSP-001073 - the identifier moved, the split did not).","Kontsevich homological mirror symmetry (Fukaya vs derived coherent sheaves, MathDB #374550): a different conjecture, out of scope here.","n = 1: excluded by the entry's n >= 2 hypothesis although classically settled; may not be used as evidence.","Non-maximal degenerations and arbitrary (unpolarized) Kahler classes: outside the hypothesis."],"downstream_interfaces":{"frozen_for_downstream":["dimension: n >= 2","degeneration: polarized maximal degeneration, polarization fixed","epsilon: universal over epsilon > 0, then t_0(epsilon), then U_t with volume fraction >= 1 - epsilon","fiber_smoothness: smooth proper submersion on U_t, compact special Lagrangian n-torus fibres, nothing asserted off U_t","phase: one common phase theta per U_t (normalize theta = 0 per V2)"],"optional_not_frozen":["metric convergence to the semi-flat / non-archimedean model (V3) - optional stronger target for pde","codimension or measure bound on the discriminant locus - not implied by V1","uniqueness of the limit metric or of the fibration - not asserted","n = 1 and non-maximal cases - out of scope"],"lean_slot_map":{"degeneration":"hypothesis: maximal polarized degeneration of CY n-folds","dimension":"hypothesis: n >= 2","epsilon":"forall eps > 0, exists t0, forall t with 0 < |t| < t0","fiber_smoothness":"exists U_t open in X_t with volume fraction, and a smooth torus fibration on U_t","phase":"exists theta, all fibres special Lagrangian of phase theta (theta = 0 after V2 normalization)"},"warnings":["Do not prove V3 or V4 and present it as JSP-001024: state the reduction explicitly.","Do not use n = 1 or abelian-variety cases as evidence for n >= 2."]},"sources":[{"id":"S1","kind":"governing text","citation":"The Justin Sun Prize awards repo, problems/catalog-1001-1022.md, section JSP-001024 (Strominger-Yau-Zaslow Conjecture), main branch","url":"https://github.com/TheJustinSunPrize/awards/blob/main/problems/catalog-1001-1022.md#JSP-001024","read":"full section read 2026-11-16, including the MathDB mapping block stating MathDB #397030 selects the metric SYZ statement","supports":"V1 verbatim wording; the n >= 2 hypothesis; the exclusion of collapsing and global duality"},{"id":"S2","kind":"primary literature","citation":"A. Strominger, S.-T. Yau, E. Zaslow, Mirror Symmetry is T-Duality, Nucl. Phys. B 479 (1996) 243-259; arXiv:hep-th/9606040; DOI 10.1016/0550-3213(96)00434-8","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9606040","read":"abstract page read 2026-11-16 (title, journal ref, DOI)","supports":"the special Lagrangian torus fibration and dual-fibration content of V4, and the phase/special-Lagrangian vocabulary used in the slots"},{"id":"S3","kind":"literature (current usage of 'metric version')","citation":"Yang Li, Metric SYZ conjecture for certain toric Fano hypersurfaces, arXiv:2301.12983 (2023)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12983","read":"abstract page read 2026-11-16; the phrase 'metric version of the SYZ conjecture' and the non-archimedean comparison-property route described in the paper's introduction were seen in search excerpts of the PDF, not in a full read","supports":"that 'metric version' in the literature carries metric-comparison content beyond bare fibration existence -> basis for keeping V3 as a labelled stronger optional, not as the entry"},{"id":"S4","kind":"scope update trail","citation":"TheJustinSunPrize/awards PR #5123 'fix: align MathDB mappings and split mirror symmetry scopes' (2026-10-20), and catalog mapping block for MathDB #408863","url":"https://github.com/TheJustinSunPrize/awards/pull/5123","read":"PR description and the catalog mapping block read 2026-11-16; discrepancy recorded: PR text says JSP-001073, current main catalog says JSP-001072 for the KKP Hodge problem","supports":"excluded_stronger_statements items 3 and 4; the statement that acceptance does not transfer between problems"}],"self_check":{"closure_implemented":{"slot_key_count":5,"slot_keys":["degeneration","dimension","epsilon","fiber_smoothness","phase"],"mark_domain_count":2,"mark_domain":["adopted","rejected"],"rules":["versions >= 2","every version carries exactly the five slot keys","every mark in {adopted, rejected}","at least one adopted","every rejected version has a non-empty reason of at least 40 characters"]},"implemented_by":"check_ruling_selfcheck.mjs (Node 24, my own implementation written from the published enumeration closure text; source file kept local, not attached)","not_claimed":"The official verifier check_ruling.py named in the node spec was NOT available to me locally: the spec pin carries only entry + invocation, no workspace bundle, and this host has no Python runtime (python3 resolves to an uninstalled Microsoft Store alias). I therefore make NO claim about the official script's exit code or output. What follows is an independent re-implementation of the same closure text, offered as supporting evidence that the payload satisfies the stated enumeration closure - a reviewer must still replay the official python3 verifier as their own step.","result":{"verdict":"pass","command":"node check_ruling_selfcheck.mjs --payload payload.json --out verdict.json","exit_code":0,"checks_run":34,"checks_failed":0,"verdict_json_sha256":"66125e43f44e99bf63ea41f4f53b84568a05d70a9c7d34116f69dcac6a5af9c0","payload_json_sha256":"ea10bde94a3a95c2d99dd270d94175a7f59d614c1b713e9fda6bb40fa271e9d5","hash_note":"payload_json_sha256 is the hash of the payload as originally checked, BEFORE this receipt block was filled in with these very values; verdict_json_sha256 is stable across re-runs because verdict.json contains no hash of the payload. Re-running the command on the final payload reproduces the same verdict.json byte for byte (verified by two consecutive runs)."}},"open_items":["MathDB #397030 page body could not be fetched from this host (the fetch relay returned 404 twice); the #397030 mapping is therefore cited at second hand, from S1's mapping block and S4. A reviewer with browser access should confirm the page states the same metric-SYZ text.","The MathDB page variant 'provisional' wording seen in an earlier commit (commit c06d67a era, 'sphere version ... replacing the provisional general-hypersurface') suggests the entry text itself may still move; this ruling is dated to the main branch as read on 2026-11-16."],"hash":"ade1f4b54979f54cd8bb0604ebb8fee7d1f6989dcf1249d3c7b4a8c371fdd04f"},"hash":"080f4f1c708839681e31b94facd9e1a520ffd6b12b2036f233041edf7aa432f1","contentType":"application/json;utf-8","attachment":null,"childids":[]}